Home > On Writing > From A to P – F – Frantic Editing

From A to P – F – Frantic Editing

This post was posted in September 2011.

In July 2011 I put up a post here on editing my novel, The Istanbul Puzzle. I had spent six weeks doing a thorough edit based on suggestions from my publisher Harper Collins. I submitted my heavily edited version soon after and hoped that that would be it, bar a final check for minor problems.

I was wrong.

A few weeks later the manuscript came back. Another editor at Harper Collins had gone through it and had a number of general issues for me to consider, as well as cuts and suggestions for every page. At first I wondered was this unusual, was my manuscript in need of extra help because it was so poorly written. The monster of self-doubt doesn’t need much encouragement to come trampling across the garden!

So, I called a long published author friend, with a dozen novels under his belt. He told me what was happening was more common that not these days and was called a “second pass” edit.  Slowly I learn the truth.

And the thought that came to me as I scanned through all the suggestions was this; don’t ever get involved in trying to get published with a major house if you don’t want to work hard. Very hard. Like seven days a week 3 – 4 hours a day until your brain hurts and your patience frays atomically thin.

But I’ve survived. And it’s over. I submitted the revised version yesterday. And I have to say that the suggestions from HC were really very good.  A much better novel is emerging. The changes are in the following areas:

  • cuts for pace, there were many of these and every rambling paragraph or word has been spotted by HC,
  • cuts in myths and legends. I had packed in too many. The new version sticks to the very best.
  • Sean and Isabel, getting their relationship right, and describing Sean more clearly early on will help readers understand the main characters better.
  • The ending. I have twisted the ending further, adding depth and a smoother ride to the bloody finale.

The novel stands at 100,700 words now. About 7,000 have been cut. It is with my editor. I await her response. I am quite happy to have another run at it, if she feels it needs it, but with the date for publication fast approaching (Jan 19) and a self-imposed deadline for a first draft of my next novel in the series,  The Jerusalem Puzzle, coming up in January too, I do hope the next edit will be a little less taxing.

For a first time published author with Harper Collins UK the big surprise for me in the past few months has been the level of hard work and the nitty-gritty editing that has been required. The editors at HC spotted every little thing that I let go, that niggled and I passed over. Don’t let any one ever tell you that the art of editing is dead at major publishers. It certainly isn’t at Harper Collins Avon.

Here is a slideshow of scenes from The Istanbul Puzzle. I will be posting more of my story from aspiring to published author over the next few months. Please subscribe on the right, down a little, if you want to learn more.

  1. 2011/09/30 at 5:40 am | #1

    There are some small publishers who do this just as well, believe me. Been through it too just now, my publication date is Jan 19. Good luck to you!

  2. 2011/09/30 at 7:28 am | #2

    Very useful and interesting. It it heartening that your editors are truly professional and want your novel to be at its best when it’s published. It sounds eminently filmable and Dan Brown (ish) – I hope that’s OK! – Do you see it hitting the silver screen in due course and being published on several continents? Am looking forward to its publication in 2012. I have not travelled to Istanbul in the past. Reading your blog and the work in progress has whetted my appetite even more. Will it be published in both hardback and paperback, or straight into paperback? Listened last night on TV to James Daunt (Daunt Books and MD at Waterstones) commenting on falling hardback sales. Hope you have the best deal possible and very best of luck. Buzzard48

  3. 2011/09/30 at 7:43 am | #3

    Thank you Charles. It is heartening indeed. I have a wonderful feeling today, a lightness that matches the weather. Another hurdle is over.

    The Istanbul Puzzle will be sold by Harper Collins UK at the Frankfurt Book Fair Oct 12-16 and I a hope other countries will take it too! Here’s to living inside a dream!

  4. 2011/09/30 at 9:42 am | #4

    You’ve got such a good attitude – I’m sure all your hard work will pay off!

    • 2011/09/30 at 10:00 am | #5

      Thanks Jenny. I feel lucky and grateful to be getting published and eager to learn all I can!

  5. 2011/10/01 at 6:41 pm | #6

    You get but one chance to make a first impression. Looking forward to seeing to book.

  6. 2011/10/01 at 6:41 pm | #7

    “the” book… not “to” book. It appears I need an editor for my comments.

    • 2011/10/02 at 10:59 am | #8

      Thanks Munk…that’s what makes me wake at 3:AM! Getting the first impression right, that is. Wishing you well!

  7. 2011/10/03 at 10:35 pm | #9

    Hi Laurence. I wanted to ask you since your original blog telling everyone that you’d been picked up by Harper Collins about the process that you were successful in securing them as publishers. Did you use an agent, did you have a recommendation?

    I’m really glad to hear that editing isn’t dead at some of the great publishers. I know, if I’m ever going to get my novel published (and it’s almost ready to submit) that fate will need my publisher (and/or agent) to be a damned good editor.

    Glad you’re enjoying the process.

    • 2011/10/04 at 9:01 am | #10

      Hi,

      No I didn’t get an agent first. I met a HC editor at an http://www.authonomy.com/ event last December for people interested in crime writing and she asked to see my novel. It took a few months, but they said yes! I am still finding out what that means!

      I wish you well with your writing. Persistence is the key!

  8. 2011/11/22 at 11:25 pm | #11

    A real insight in editing.
    But how did you get a publisher and an agent.
    I have no contacts in the industry.

    • 2011/11/23 at 4:24 am | #12

      Hi Ali,

      I attended about 6 writers conferences in the States and Europe. I met editors and agents at these conferences. That’s the way to build contacts, but it does take time.

  1. 2012/08/10 at 5:04 pm | #1

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 44,706 other followers

%d bloggers like this: